An Entirely Fictitious Account of Doctor Who – The Doctor Who Companion https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com Get your daily fix of news, reviews, and features with the Doctor Who Companion! Sat, 18 Nov 2023 12:53:46 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.4 108589596 An Entirely Fictitious Account of DR WHO https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2023/11/23/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-dr-who/ https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2023/11/23/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-dr-who/#respond Thu, 23 Nov 2023 00:01:00 +0000 https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/?p=39341

Despite being voted the longest-running science fiction television series of all time, very little has been written about the early years of Dr WHO. But, at last, we have uncovered the secret history of TV’s venerable Timelord traveller in time/space. Let’s time-skip back more than 47 years to the nineteen hundred and sixties…

It begins with a feisty Canadian firebrand called Syd Numan who angrily arrived at the BBC in 1963 demanding that they scrap all their prestigious costume dramas and instead produce a “TV series for oddball infants who like science, history, and geometry. Or you will all get a jolly good smacked bottom!” Because he was all red in the face and in an uncontrollable rage, the frightened BBC management gave him £426, seven shillings and sixpence to produce 87 episodes a year until at least 1993.

Within minutes, Numan became bored of the idea exclaiming, “What a load of crackpot!” So he blackmailed two confused older gents, Don Winston and CBE ‘Bunny Boy’ Webster (CBE) into taking over. Both were highly experienced old-school BBC producers and, as such, had no idea what they were doing.

Winston was keen for the series to be about a mysterious ‘twerp’ stranded on planet Earth because his time machine was irreparable. Episodes would centre around his bungling efforts to fix the ship and, frustratingly, never exploring the whole of space and time; while ‘Bunny Boy’ wanted the stories to feature a team of adventurers, ‘the teenies’, whose time machine had shrunk them so small they were invisible and inaudible. “It would be very cheap because you wouldn’t need any actors,” ‘Bunny Boy’ insisted.

Numan declared both these ideas as, “Total dishwater!” So, with only half an hour left before production started, they went back to the drawing board. Out of their frantic, manic drawings, as they sobbed hot tears, a TV legend was born… Dr WHO!

The lead character would be known as ‘Doctor ?’ because he had forgotten to write down his second name, and – now more than 7 million years old – he is too embarrassed to go back and ask*. He is described as a ‘randy old codger’ who lives in a junk shop where his ship ‘Tar-Dis’ has crash-landed, with his great-granddaughter, Sue-Ann.

Tar-Dis is the most powerful space-time/time-space ship in the known solar system but it looks really crap because the BBC didn’t have the budget for anything better. The ship is pretending to be a London Police BOX, which is why ‘Dr WHO’ is often mistaken for a policeman [An AI wrote that sentence].

Sue-Ann escapes ‘Doctor’s’ clutches and, despite being more than 108, seeks refuge at the local primary school, pretending to be six years old. Her history teacher, Iain Chestnut, is suspicious because – unlike the rest of the class – Sue-Ann refuses to take a nap in the afternoons and instead dances to beat music in her fab swinging sixties gear while talking about the day she stormed the Bastille.

Chestnut tells his colleagues (and secret lovers) science teacher, Babs Right, and geometry teacher, Babs Left, about his suspicions. Babs Right also airs her concerns: Sue-Ann had taken over the class and taught them how to make a nuclear fusion reactor. Babs Left had measured Sue-Ann and found her to be transcendentally dimensional. They decide to confront her mysterious great-grandpa in his junk pile…

When he found out much later, Numan described this new idea as, ‘Unforgivable tripe!’, then beat his fists against the studio wall until he drew blood. But there was no time to come up with anything better. The red light was on and filming had started…

Winston and ‘Bunny Boy’ had gone into hiding, leaving the show to be produced by the unknown fresh-faced, inexperienced, wet-behind-the-ears, Varsity Lamppost. She quickly dried the back of her ears and proved herself to be a billion times more competent than those two jokers. Despite being left with an opening episode written on 26 stitched-together fag packets, and eight further episodes set in the prehistoric era where the only word in the script was ‘grunt’, Varsity set to work.

She cast veteran screen idol, Billy Harnell as Doctor One, after her first choice, Dicky ‘Sir Pastry’ Lewes Misheard demanded that ‘Doctor’ should be “made out of pastry” (The BBC effects department vetoed this idea after an unsuccessful screen test: “Pastry got everywhere.”)

Harnell was keen to take on the role and perform in front of infants, having only played serial killers and bungling burglars up to this point. To soften his gruesome image, he insisted that his dialogue should include, “plenty of confusing nonsense and stupid-sounding errors” – these became known as ‘Billy fluffs’ or ‘Flufbills’.

The rest of the cast was made up of The Adventures of Sir Reginald Styles actor William Russell Enoch Russell (credited as Will E Russell), Jacqueline and Jilleline Hills (joint winners of Miss Cardigan 1958) as Babs Right and Babs Left, and Caro-Line Form as Sue-Ann. Form was 47 and had the tricky task of playing a 108-year-old pretending to be a 6-year-old acting like a teenager.

Performing in Dr WHO was a terrifying experience for these actors because, for the first five years, the show was recorded and broadcast live on stage in front of an unresponsive audience. And the very first episode proved to be a disaster.

Lamppost had appointed an untested, experimental new director, Warrick Hassan, who insisted that the sound of ‘banging doors’ featured loudly throughout the episode. Numan was enraged and ripped the curtain down at the end of the recording, taking to the stage to rant about the script, production, performances, and the state of his dressing room: “No bidet! You animals!”

He was furious that some of the dialogue had spoilt the mystery of the programme. At one point, Sue-Ann says, “We are aliens from the 49th century, part of a new science-fiction series that aims to bridge the gap on Saturday evenings between Grandstand and the pop music show Juke Box Jury. And also appeal to both audiences.”

With Numan sedated and incarcerated, Lamppost and Hussan set to work on a revised episode one. It started with a caption declaring: ‘PLEASE IGNORE LAST WEEK’S EPISODE’. This time, it was a success, with the audience cheering and applauding at the end. But little did they know that outside the studio, world events would scupper their second opening night…

While the episode was being broadcast, the President of the USA, John F Kenny was assassinated with a bullet. Whilst sad for America, it was a disaster for Dr WHO. With many viewers listening to the news instead of the BBC’s new science fiction series, the production team decided to remount the show the next week. It was another huge success, with many of the crowd calling for an encore: Harnell obliged by performing his ‘bungling burglar’ routine. But disaster struck again when, during the broadcast, the US President was shot for the second time in as many weeks. The production team reluctantly decided that, this time, they had to move on…

The remounted episode was followed by the ‘erotic caveman’ story, Tribe of Mummies, which proved to be a huge turn-off for viewers. The cast grunted their way in prehistoric times for the next eight weeks until Doctor hit the tribe leader on the head with a rock, and they made their escape, to the delight of both the Tar-Dis crew and the audience.

But it was the next story, The Deadly Planet AKA These Mutants AKA The Luxor Masters (the programme’s longest-ever episode title), that secured the show’s future. In desperation, Lamppost asked a failed comedian, Terrance National Express (TNE), to write the story. Strapped for cash, after being commissioned, TNE wrote seven scripts in the corridor outside Lampost’s office in about an hour, the last being just three words, “…and so on”. Then he stole the scriptwriting fee and flew away like a thief. Little did he know that he had accidentally written a masterstroke.

The Deadly Planet AKA These Mutants AKA The Luxor Masters pitted Doctor and his crew against a suitably deadly foe: Darleks. These robot creatures from the planet Scarred resembled upturned egg cups and spoke with an evil rasping cackle. While both infants and the fully-grown loved these fascist, murdering psychopaths, there was one man who took exasperated umbrage: the show’s own birth father, Syd Numan. He had been revived in order to attend the recording. But when Darleks appeared, he once again invaded the stage. In a fit of rage, Numan cried, “No BEMs! I said no BEMs,” before being dragged back into the wings by Jacqueline and Jilleline Hills.

The audience was shocked to witness this agonised outburst. Lamppost took to the stage and calmed the crowd, who assumed Numan had meant ‘No Black and Ethnic Minorities’. She explained that in Dr WHO’s DNA document, Numan had insisted the show should not include ‘Boggle Eyed Monstrosities’, and that’s what he thought the Darleks were. At that point, Numan freed himself from his shackles and burst back on stage.

The crowd started chanting: “We love Darleks, more psychopathic BEMs! More monstrous killers!” Numan was taken aback and his life-long, uncontrollable rage briefly subsided. He embraced Lamppost and declared, “I was so, so wrong! Bring on the BEMs!” In tears, he called the cast back to finish the episode.

This time, no president was assassinated and 53,508,513 viewers tuned in – the entire population of the UK, except for Dicky ‘Sir Pastry’ Lewes Misheard who couldn’t watch because he was still encased in pastry. Following this huge, runaway success, the BBC decided to destroy all copies of all the episodes forever.

That is the totally unbelievable story of the longest-running science fiction series in the world – as voted by you – which has now been on our screens for more than 47 years. The rest, as they say, is Dr WHO’s history, science and geometry…

* There is a clue to Doctor’s forgotten surname in the very first episode, The Unhappy Childhood: on the junk shop gates a sign declares: ‘I’m Foreman’.

]]>
https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2023/11/23/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-dr-who/feed/ 0 39341
An Entirely Fictitious Account of Doctor Who: The Ghost Monument https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2022/09/25/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-doctor-who-the-ghost-monument/ https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2022/09/25/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-doctor-who-the-ghost-monument/#respond Sun, 25 Sep 2022 00:01:00 +0000 https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/?p=36395

“My main starting point for The Ghost Monument was finding out that humans can survive unaided in deep space for up to 12 minutes,” Chris Chibnail and I, then-showrunner of Doctor Who revealed to Psychics Monthly, the magazine for physicists who can’t spell. “I think I learned that in a dream, but it’s definitely true and if you ever get the chance to go into space without a spacesuit, any breathing equipment, or protection whatsoever, I advise you to do so. I’ve been. Again, in a dream, but I’m sure that’s fine.”

(Our lawyers have advised us to note that you should, under no circumstances, do this. You know, in case NASA rocks up at your door and asks for you to go on an experimental mission around the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter wearing only your pyjamas and some discount crocs from Asda.)

This scene, with the Doctor and her new possible-reluctant-companions, possible-kidnapped-victims floating in the wildness of space, proved to be not only a great opener for The Ghost Monument but also a shocking cliffhanger for Jodie Whittaker’s debut episode, The Woman Who Fell Down to the Planet Below Her, By Heck. Fortunately, Chris consulted several astrophysicists (well, two of them) to confirm that the characters could be saved from their potentially-grisly deaths in space if a spaceship were passing by at just the right time; and further that space is absolutely full of spaceships. “You can hardly move for spaceships,” said an unnamed source who goes under the pseudonym Mr C. Chibnail and I.

The Ghost Monument found the Doctor, Officer Yasmin Khan PCDA QVC AOL, O’Graham O’Brien, and Ryan on the desolate planet called Desolation which was pretty darn desolated and was located in a desolate part of space in this desolate universe, as they competed in a race to reach the titular Ghostly Monument. “I bet it’s the TARDIS,” said numerous commenters, fans, casual viewers, blind nuns, Gary Barlow, and a woman called June who works in the Cardiff branch of Lego. “I bet it’s the TARDIS too,” said Chris Chibnail and I.

And though some select viewers had already guessed what said Ghostly Monument would turn out to be, the production team had a secret surprise concealed up their metaphorical sleeves: killer toilet paper.

“I think everyone has, at one point in their lives, thought, ‘what if I go to the bathroom and after casting out my unmentionables, I reach out to grasp the toilet paper and instead of cleaning up after my ablutions, it starts to strangle me and I start screaming and yelling for help but no words leave my lips because the Andrex is that triple-ply sort?’” Chris told Psychiatrists Weekly, the weighty tome for psychics who can’t spell. “So I thought I’d channel those nightmares into Doctor Who.”

The showrunner’s dreams, night terrors, and psychotic episodes further inspired the rest of the story. Those fears include: a desert; some water; solar-power; some tunnels; a self-lighting cigar; and Art Malik in a tent.

“It was pretty high-octane stuff,” one doped-out anonymous viewer told Points of View from his cell.

Though sentient loo roll wasn’t a great challenge for the design team to realise, they had their work cut out for them when it came to creating SniperBots, described in the script as “camouflaged robots, head-to-toe in khaki, wearing hoodies, one arm replaced by a massive gun, and their face a black box with one shining bright eye in the centre, like Cyclops from the X-Men”.

“When we first saw the word ‘SniperBot’ in the script,” explained Supervising Art Director, Dafydd Shurmer, in the November 2018 issue of In Vogue, a magazine dedicated to reporting about what was in the previous month’s issue of Vogue, “I thought they’d be so far away, we wouldn’t need to design them. You never see snipers up close, right? They’re always like… over there. In the distance. So I thought we could just do a silhouette or something. Maybe a plank of wood with a face drawn on it in Sharpie. Sadly, Chris was worried the audience would confuse them with Ryan, so instead, we simply designed the SniperBots as camouflaged robots, head-to-toe in khaki, wearing hoodies, one arm replaced by a massive gun, and their face a black box with one shining bright eye in the centre, like Cyclops from the X-Men.”

“I wasn’t happy with the design,” Chibnail and I later complained in an episode of Open Air. “Totally not what I’d envisioned.”

That would be the only controversial thing in The Ghost Monument. On a completely unrelated topic, the episode also featured the first mention of the Timeless Children.

The Ghost Monument further gave the series one of its most iconic images, courtesy of guest star, Shaun Dooley. The image showed the silhouette of Jodie’s Doctor against a dazzling sky, the TARDIS in sight, with fresh new adventures beckoning and a whole universe of wonder ready to be discovered. “I was trying to take a selfie, but got my phone the wrong way round,” Dooley told everyone who would listen.

Whittaker was especially pleased with it and asked him to send it to Chibnail and I. She told Nightly Northern News for the Northern Nation: “ey up, ey up, eyy upp. Eyyy ooop, ey up, ey oop, eyy uppp, whippets, ey up.” The picture was then used on the steelbook version of Series 11.

“I wasn’t happy with the design,” Chibnail and I later complained in an episode of Open Air. “Totally not what I’d envisioned.”

At the conclusion of the episode, the Doctor got back to her TARDIS, only to be surprised with a new interior design. After throwing up for numerous hours, seeing a therapist for six weekly sessions, and writing letters of complaint to the BBC, the Doctor realised that this was still her TARDIS and, epzo facto, was charged with getting it off Desolation. “I was very happy with the design,” Chibnail and I said in an issue of Physicists Daily, the newspaper for psychiatrists who can spell but have delusions of grandeur. “Totally what I’d envisioned.”

And so, with a new title sequence, new TARDIS trio made up of four people, a new direction, a new costume, a new showrunner, and Bradley Walsh, Series 11 was off to a refreshing start. In the coming weeks, Doctor Who would teach viewers that racism is bad, spiders are bad, things that eat too much are bad, dying is bad, Amazon is bad, sexism is bad, child abuse is surprisingly forgivable, and revenge is bad.

]]>
https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2022/09/25/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-doctor-who-the-ghost-monument/feed/ 0 36395
What If… Leonardo da Vinci Became Doctor Who Showrunner? https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2021/09/12/what-if-leonardo-da-vinci-became-doctor-who-showrunner/ https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2021/09/12/what-if-leonardo-da-vinci-became-doctor-who-showrunner/#respond Sun, 12 Sep 2021 01:56:00 +0000 http://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/?p=33207

“I am The Watcher. I am your guide through these vast new realities. Follow me and dare to face the unknown, and ponder the question, ‘What if’…?”

Leonardo da Vinci was a man ahead of his time. CENTURIES ahead of his time.

We can talk about his art of course. His collection of Mona Lisas, etc (although only one’s real).

Perhaps his revolutionary, groundbreaking work studying human anatomy, making discoveries about human organs, including how the heart works with blood flow, well before anyone else. Indeed, he was the first human to sketch many human organs.

He, more than anyone else, knew humans inside and out.

But I think maybe some need a reminder about his prowess at invention.

As concepts go, he first conceived the use of concentrated solar power, the calculator, theorized plate tectonics, and much more.

He conceptualized the tank, over 400 years before its creation. In modern times, a team built said tank to his design specs. This war machine had over 30 gun placements and was completely operational. They only had to change one single gear, which was thought to have been specifically placed as a red herring by da Vinci to thwart anyone who might try and steal his designs.

He was a pioneer in robotics. His sketches and schematics for what has become known as “Leonardo’s Mechanical Knight” were utilised and the creation built in 2002 by NASA personnel. It worked. 

He designed a workable precursor to the modern diving suit. 

He conceptualized the parachute, glider, helicopter, and landing gear.

He discovered the processes governing friction.

He designed the first self propelled machine — an early ancestor to the automobile.

It’s said that many of his designs were lost over time, or at least never rediscovered, so it’s difficult to know what we’re missing. But here’s a man who had an instinctive knowledge of science, the human condition, could conceive of the inner workings of fantastic inventions centuries before their actual creation.

These conceptualisations of the tank, diving suit, weapons, submarine, helicopter, numerous machines such as the lens grinder, all these sketches and designs — those were things that could in some way be explained to some of the higher thinkers of his time. They certainly made sense in the modern era, where our tech finally caught up with da Vinci. These were things we recognised.

But what about the concepts that were deemed pure fantasy back in Leonardo’s day? That are still deemed an intriguing impossibility today? This was a man who could create anything. Who’s to say he didn’t have other, more fantastic plans?

Did Leonardo da Vinci, using his incredible and instinctive knowledge of science, combined with his innate ability to create amazingly complex machines, build the very first time machine? 

And if this fantastic creation is hurtling through time — PERHAPS AS WE SPEAK — would Leonardo come to the here and now and be… the new showrunner for Doctor Who?!?!?!

No, of course not.

1. He’d want to direct or be director of photography or something similar.

And 2. He’s going to far more interesting places.

Besides, the job’s a hassle. 

But it’s fun to think about!

So what if anyone in time and space could be the new showrunner? Who would you pick? Who is in charge of Doctor Who somewhere in this vast multiverse?

]]>
https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2021/09/12/what-if-leonardo-da-vinci-became-doctor-who-showrunner/feed/ 0 33207
An Unearthly Timeless Child: What If Chris Chibnall Wrote for the First Doctor? https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2021/04/09/an-unearthly-timeless-child-what-if-chris-chibnall-wrote-for-the-first-doctor/ https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2021/04/09/an-unearthly-timeless-child-what-if-chris-chibnall-wrote-for-the-first-doctor/#respond Fri, 09 Apr 2021 04:41:00 +0000 http://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/?p=30956

Author’s note: the following is offered in a spirit of fun and is intended, like Vorg’s Scoop, to amuse – simply to amuse. It isn’t meant to be taken too seriously and is certainly not meant to sneer at those who, perfectly legitimately, enjoy Chris Chibnall’s era of Doctor Who. We’re all enriched by our different opinions, after all.

I just wondered what it might have been like if Chris Chibnall, rather than Verity Lambert, had helmed the early Doctor Who stories.

Here’s what some of them might have looked like…

An Unearthly Child

Schoolteachers Ian and Barbara are worried about one of their pupils, Susan, who isn’t doing too well with her homework. They track her home through the fog to a junkyard in Totter’s Lane, Shoreditch. There, they find a police box and a mysterious stranger: a cheerful, bubbly lady who’s really pleased to see them and welcomes them to her nice junkyard. The stranger explains that she’s called the Doctor and has a time machine called a TARDIS and that she’s a Time Lord, well sort of, but she’s actually recently discovered she’s really the Timeless Child who’s lived for billions of years and has forgotten most of what she did until the last 2000 years or so. This explanation goes on for 10 minutes and the schoolteachers politely try not to look bored. The Doctor had overheard Barbara telling Ian to “use a match” to illuminate the gloom and surmises he must have matches to light cigarettes with; she tells him off for being a smoker and says it’s very, very bad to smoke and he’s setting a very, very bad example to the lovely young people he teaches. Reeling from the harangue, Ian craves a cigarette but he can’t because he’s left his Woodbines in the staff room. The Doctor is, though, very grateful to Ian and Barbara for their concern about Susan’s homework and says it’s very, very important that all children do their homework so that they can all do well at school and go on to live happy and fulfilled lives. (This last speech is delivered straight to camera.)

The Doctor invites Ian and Barbara to travel with her in time and space and they happily agree. They enter the TARDIS and the Doctor re-introduces them to her granddaughter. They travel to prehistoric Earth. The Doctor tells Za that he must be nice to Kal because Kal is from another tribe and is therefore a foreigner and that therefore they must all be nice to him because that would be nice.

The Doctor intervenes in the power struggle between Kal and Za and shows the tribe how to hold elections, based on the proportional representation single transferable vote system. After an entire episode of mucking about with different coloured pebbles being placed into hollowed out stones, Hur (who the Doctor campaigned for) is elected leader and an age of prosperity, with food and fire for all, follows. Ian is overjoyed when he is shown how to make fire by the Old Mother (who knew how to do it all along but wasn’t going to say because she doesn’t like how the men had all the power and got to make all the decisions). A sabre-toothed tiger tries to jump on Za but the Doctor intervenes, tickling it between its ears until it calms down and rolls over on its back so the Doctor can tickle its tummy. She tells the tribe they mustn’t kill and eat beautiful animals like this because they’re beautiful and animals and that animals have rights too, and she shows them which plants they should eat. The whole tribe eagerly embrace vegetarianism. The Doctor and her Fam depart in the TARDIS, but not before the Doctor has given Za a big hug.  

In return, Za has given her a big bunch of flowers from the Tribe’s local retailer, The Florist of Fear.

The Daleks

The pacifist Thals will not fight the Daleks, evil intelligences housed in metal casings. Ian tries to organise the Thals into a fighting force. The Doctor is aghast. How dare Ian impose his violent ideas on a peace-loving people? We must respect their viewpoint and never, never try to change anyone’s minds. “Good on you, chuck,” she tells Alydon when he explains his people will not fight the Daleks. The TARDIS crew beam seraphically on the Thals and the Doctor explains to the Fam that they have all learnt something new today: that violence never, ever pays. They wish the Thals all the very best and depart in the TARDIS.

However, the Daleks have by now worked out how to leave their city and they find the Thals and kill them all.

The Edge of Destruction

The Doctor is very cross with Susan when she goes mad and tries to attack Ian with a pair of scissors. She patiently explains to the dim teenager that we must all live in peace and that talking to someone and explaining your point of view calmly but assertively is much more productive than any attempted homicidal assault with domestic implements. The Doctor shows Susan how to use scissors in a much more productive way and the TARDIS Fam all sit down together to cut doilies out of pretty paper.

The Aztecs

The Doctor doesn’t want to stop the Aztec practice of human sacrifice because, as she explains, we must respect the Aztecs’ culture, that any deviation from moral relativism is always morally wrong (except when it is to condemn deviation from moral relativism), and that if the Aztecs believe that ripping people’s hearts out will make the sun rise tomorrow, then who are we to say this deeply held belief is incorrect?

However, the Doctor is worried that the practice of throwing the corpses of the recently mutilated off the top of the ziggurat will pollute the environment and might interfere with the delicate balance of the eco-system because pollution is very, very bad. So she distracts the Aztecs from carrying out any more sacrifices by organising a big party where they all sit down together and drink lots of yummy cocoa. A distraught Tlotoxl bursts into tears at this moving scene. The Doctor persuades the Aztecs to elect Cameca as the new High Priest of Sacrifice and everyone lives happily ever after.

The Reign of Terror

The Doctor and her Fam arrive in France during the Revolution. The Doctor applauds the spirit of the Revolution because it will make the lot of the oppressed in France much, much better, and she explains to the Fam how the guillotine is actually a measure designed to improve human rights because it is much more humane than previous methods of capital punishment as it was designed to end life instantaneously. But capital punishment is very, very naughty and should be abolished. The Doctor’s rousing speech gives great comfort to Barbara and Susan and they remember it when they’re in a tumbril on the way to the guillotine.

The Doctor patiently explains to the Fam, too, that there are lots of other good things about the Revolution, especially as it got rid of the monarchy, and the concept of a monarchy is very, very bad because it’s very, very bad that people should live lives of privilege based simply on who their family was rather than on the enlightened principle of a meritocracy where talent will always win out, as we know it always will.

The TARDIS food machine has run out of bread and the Doctor explains that’s all right as it will let them eat cake instead.

The Dalek Invasion of Earth

The Doctor is thrilled to meet Dortman, a scientist confined to a wheelchair, and she patiently explains to him that disabled people are just as good as everybody else, and he shouldn’t stop trying to be a scientist just because he is in a wheelchair. Dortman tells her a) to stop patronising him and b) that no amount of wittering will help defeat the Daleks. The Doctor sulks for the rest of the episode.

The Doctor realises the true extent of the Daleks’ villainy when she learns that their dehumanised human slaves are called Robomen. She goes down to the River Thames by Hammersmith Bridge, where the Daleks like to go sub-aqua diving. A Dalek has just emerged from its daily swim and she patiently explains to it that women are just as capable as men to be reduced to zombies and that the Daleks should make sure that at least 50% of their recruits are women and that they should call their slaves “Robopersons” instead. The dripping but enraged Dalek fires its gun at her and she runs away.

The Doctor meets the Slyther, the Daleks’ pet from their home planet, who snacks on human slave workers. Having made friends with the Slyther, the Doctor leads it by the paw to the lush patches of stinging nettles that grow in abundance in the Dalek labour camp. The Slyther tucks in to the tasty vegetation and decides it likes the taste better than humans and anyway, it doesn’t have to spit the buttons out afterwards. So, there is no need to chuck the Slyther down a mine shaft, which was Ian’s preferred scheme.

When the Daleks decide to blow up half of London with a Dalekanium bomb, the Doctor calls on the help of her cute friend the Pting, who she has brought with her in the TARDIS from another world. The Pting gobbles up the bomb, which then explodes in his stomach and makes him a bit fatter when it goes off. Then the Pting burps and everybody laughs and laughs.

The Daleks realise they are no match for the Doctor and fly their ships back to Skaro, vowing to develop temporal technology so they can pursue the Doctor and her Fam through all of time and space and finally have their revenge.

The Web Planet

The Doctor will not allow the Menoptra to pursue their terrorist campaign against the Zarbi because terrorism is very, very bad and although the Zarbi are insects, we must respect all life. She entices the Zarbi into a big room and locks them all in together, where they will live out their natural lives in peace. When Ian points out this means they will either starve to death or eat each other, she scowls and doesn’t talk to him again for the rest of the story.

But of course, this opens up other parallel worlds in which Douglas Adams wrote for the Second Doctor, Robert Holmes introduced us to the Eleventh Doctor, and Steven Moffat helmed an American reboot in 1996. What other tales from the multiverse would you like to glimpse?

]]>
https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2021/04/09/an-unearthly-timeless-child-what-if-chris-chibnall-wrote-for-the-first-doctor/feed/ 0 30956
Imbeciles United: An alternative history of Harry Sullivan https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2018/03/01/imbeciles-united-an-alternative-history-of-harry-sullivan/ https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2018/03/01/imbeciles-united-an-alternative-history-of-harry-sullivan/#respond Thu, 01 Mar 2018 08:30:06 +0000 http://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/?p=14740

It seems hard to believe, when you look back on it, that Harry Sullivan was originally only going to be in Doctor Who for a single series.
Harry – played to perfection by Ian Marter – is one of the show’s most beloved companions, faithful and steadfast, if prone to occasional bouts of stupidity. Despite earning the Doctor’s wrath on more than one occasion, his sense of pluck, resolve and loyalty never wavered throughout his two years in the TARDIS, from that first appearance as the newly-regenerated Doctor’s physician in Robot to that eloquent farewell in the closing moments of The Seeds Of Doom. It’s impossible to imagine the likes of Planet of Evil or Pyramids of Mars without him, and yet it came so close to not happening, – because, as is well-documented, Harry very nearly jumped ship after his encounter with the Zygons.
According to a popular urban legend, the original decision to dispense with Harry was made purely on the basis that the character felt redundant. Tom Baker was not the older man the creative team had initially envisaged casting, and was able to do most of his own stunts; hence the need for a younger man to handle the action sequences (Terrance Dicks pithily refers to this construct to as ‘The Muscle of Russell’) was eradicated overnight, and it was felt that three was a crowd, at least in the TARDIS.
It’s a reasonable theory, but it couldn’t be further from the truth – as Dicks himself would later attest.

Harry and Sarah Jane Smith in a scene from Pyramids of Mars.

“It was the hair,” he admitted in 1998. “The problem was that Ian, bless him, was just too damned curly. And that wouldn’t have been a problem were it not for Tom, who was – and I think it may have been me who coined this expression – all teeth and curls. So we worried about the look of the thing and whether it was odd having two curly-haired gentlemen sharing the screen. ‘Course, Harry’s actually more bouffant than outright curly, but it was still a problem. I remember Barry thought I was overreacting, but my concern was that they’d look like two of those colonists you used to run into all the time in the show’s earlier years, the ones who were usually too stupid to realise the air above ground was perfectly breathable. So we ummed and ahhed about it for quite a long time. It’s funny, really, when you look back, because I honestly don’t know what we were worrying about. It was the seventies. Everybody was permed!”

The decision to retain Harry beyond his original point of departure – the final episode of Terror of the Zygons – was comparatively last-minute, and led to some hasty rewriting. Some of this is more obvious than others. Certain scenes, for instance, are on the verge of lapsing into cliche when it is clear that Harry has nothing to add to a conversation that was originally supposed to take place between only two characters – as this extract from Seeds of Doom proves in abundance.
SARAH: Well, what is a Krynoid? I mean, what does it do?
HARRY: Yes, what does it do?
DOCTOR: I suppose you could call it a galactic weed, except it’s deadlier than any weed you know.
SARAH: In what way?
HARRY: Yes, in what way?
DOCTOR: Well, on most planets, the animals eat the vegetation, hmm?
SARAH: Mmm hmm.
HARRY: Obviously.
DOCTOR: On planets where the Krynoid gets established, the vegetation eats the animals.
SARAH: But that’s terrifying.
DOCTOR: Yes.
HARRY: It’s more than that, it’s petrifying.
DOCTOR: Oh, shut up, Harry.
Other changes are more complicated, but pruning the narrative tree can bear unexpected fruit, The Android Invasion being perhaps the best known example. In the original script, Sarah Jane was supposed to come across an android version of Harry, but after rewrites the the character was changed to the Brigadier, in what would be the final 1970s appearance for Nicholas Courtney – and setting the stage for an anecdote on which he would dine out for many years afterwards.
“It was an interesting way to go out,” Courtney told Doctor Who Magazine in 1989, “and as far as I was concerned, of course, that’s exactly what I was doing. Because that whole duplicate scenario rather reminded me of the version of the Brigadier that featured in Inferno, so of course that’s how I played it. Of course, in this instance I was supposed to be the Brigadier’s exact double, so I kept the uniform and the facial hair – everything was correct to the last detail. But Ian obviously knew about what happened when we filmed Inferno – someone had clearly told him. And during that scene where he’s strapped to the table I’m supposed to look off camera and bark out an order, and then turn back to interrogate him some more. And when I turned round, he was lying there wearing an eye patch!”
While some of the rewriting passed without incident, there were other stories in which the affable lieutenant simply didn’t fit, and thus the decision was made to temporarily remove him from the action – with often comic results. In Pyramids of Mars, for example, Harry spends the first two episodes locked in the TARDIS lavatory, where he passes the time by reading a particular book that led to one of the most infamous fourth wall-breaking moments in the show’s history.
Harry whiles away the hours in the TARDIS WC. According to a leaked internal memo, BBC bosses lambasted Philip Hinchcliffe, adding that it was “a bloody good thing Points of View is on hiatus”.

“We had complaints about that,” Hinchcliffe admits. “Some from the parents who objected to what was quite literally toilet humour, but mostly from the die-hard fans who wanted to know why we put a Doctor Who annual on the shelf. The truth is that Lewis [Greifer] and I thought it would be funny, and Robert Holmes was eventually persuaded. But for many fans, it’s too much. They felt we were making a mockery of the show. The funny thing is they did something very similar in Remembrance of the Daleks and no one bats an eyelid. But I got hate mail. One chap actually burned his Doctor Who books – books which would probably go for quite a sum in the Amazon Marketplace – and then posted me the ashes with a note reading ‘DOCTOR WHO DIED TODAY’. Years later, it’s still just about the second most popular complaint I’m asked to address at conventions, right next to the Young Harry scene.”
Ah yes, that one. Hinchcliffe refers – as if anyone needed reminding – to the moment in The Brain of Morbius where Harry stumbles into the Sacred Flame and instantly regresses to childhood, much to the Doctor’s amusement. The three episodes in which he features have passed into Doctor Who production lore, with many behind-the-scenes rumours still unconfirmed thanks to the terms of several superinjunctions – and despite Hinchcliffe’s reassurances that the change was transient from the outset.
“It was never intended to be permanent,” he insists. “There’s a common consensus that once word got out, we re-wrote Seeds of Doom and brought Harry back to adulthood faster than we’d originally intended. But it was only ever intended to be a three-episode appearance, largely because Tom didn’t take to the character at all – ‘a f**king bad idea made even f**king worse’, I think were his exact words. Many people hate it because they consider it paved the way towards Adric, who was universally despised, and that Adric would never have existed if we hadn’t had Young Harry. I’m not sure I believe that, but I do seem to be in the minority.”
The infamous moment Young Harry steps out of the flames in The Brain of Morbius.

And what of the rumours behind Robin Leopold-Agnew, the thirteen-year-old stage school prodigy chosen to play Harry’s teenage self? It’s something that’s generally off limits to journalists, largely because when you ask anyone about it the results tend to be unprintable.
The late, lamented Elisabeth Sladen was more diplomatic. “He wasn’t easy to work with,” she said in 2004, “but I think that’s largely because he was so precocious. And of course after he’d dropped out of stage school, he went into politics and became Margaret Thatcher’s golden boy. I was going to say that he’d obviously realised acting wasn’t for him, but I suppose in many ways he never really left it.”
Certainly the rumours about Leopold-Agnew’s on-set behaviour – including the notorious Mushroom Soup Incident, terminology which has acquired the sort of legendary status to rival Jump The Shark – put a dampener on the character, and cast and crew alike were relieved when Marter returned for what remained of his final story.
Seeds of Doom was wonderful for Harry,” says Hinchcliffe, “although he very nearly didn’t come out of it alive. In the first draft he wound up in Harrison Chase’s compost machine when his cravat got stuck. It was going to be the episode three cliffhanger, and we were going to resolve it with Sarah Jane weeping over the machine and lamenting that she never told Harry that she loved him. It would have been a brilliant piece of work, but Mary Whitehouse was good friends with Douglas Camfield and when she found out she threatened to chain herself to the BBC railings. Normally that sort of thing is good for Doctor Who, but on this occasion the men upstairs told me I had to commission another ending.”
The Seeds of Doom: Harry’s intense phone conversation with UNIT as Amelia Ducat (Sylvia Coleridge) attempts to listen in.

In the event, of course, Harry drove off into the sunset – quite literally – with Amelia Ducat, having been enlisted as her personal chauffeur. It seemed an obviously mundane exit for a character who was happier with his feet on the ground, and given that this was the last time we would see Harry on screen – Marter’s untimely death in 1986 putting paid to any further appearances – it was a fitting send-off.
“Harry’s arc in Season 13 was an interesting one,” says Gareth Roberts. “He goes from being this reluctant traveller to someone who starts to enjoy it almost as much as Sarah Jane; it’s reflected in the way his outfits change. So it’s curious how, when he meets Amelia, he remembers how much he missed life on Earth. And they have that lovely conversation about it.”
That conversation – the memorable “tea and scones and buttered toast” monologue – is so famous it doesn’t need reprinting here, but it had so much impact on Roberts that he would eventually go on to pay homage to Seeds with his own episode, 2008’s Plant Life.
“I’d have dearly, dearly loved to bring Harry back for that story,” he says. “But I didn’t want to recast a dead actor. As it stood, we had Lis, and we had John Challis, and thanks to a nod from Russell [T. Davies], we managed to pay tribute to Ian in the best way possible.”
Two scenes from Plant Life (2008): Top – the Doctor, Sarah Jane and Scorby face off against the terror that Scorby has unleashed. Bottom – the Doctor, Donna and Sarah Jane gather to pay their respects to a former comrade.

And when we look back at Harry, and the moments that defined him (the worm-eating scenes in Planet of Evil, the organ recital in Pyramids) it’s curious that perhaps the pinnacle of defining moments is one in which he doesn’t actually feature, at least on screen. The scene in question – where the Doctor, Donna and Sarah Jane, having vanquished the villainous Scorby, unite round Harry’s grave – stands as one of the most touching moments of Series 4, even more so because the act of remembrance isn’t just about Harry, but the man who played him. “I move on,” says the Doctor, staring down at the headstone. “I mean, I have to. But that doesn’t mean you forget. You never forget. People die. And sometimes that means I can never see them again – some things even a Time Lord can’t manage. But they never leave, not really. And that’s why I’m glad I’ve got two hearts. It makes it easier to carry people with you.”
We mine a well-worn cliché – not to mention a dangerous misstep – when we suggest that we should be living our lives like the Doctor, but this is probably one of those times when it’s not a bad aspiration.

]]>
https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2018/03/01/imbeciles-united-an-alternative-history-of-harry-sullivan/feed/ 0 14740
An Entirely Fictitious Account of The Richard E Grant Years https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2016/11/12/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-the-richard-e-grant-years/ https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2016/11/12/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-the-richard-e-grant-years/#comments Sat, 12 Nov 2016 09:40:27 +0000 http://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/?p=6538

It seems hard to believe now that Doctor Who’s phenomenal revival was all thanks to a simple Flash animation.
Picture the scene: it’s 2003, and Russell T Davies’ constant lobbying for a TV resurrection is beginning to bear fruit. He’s had to compete with Matthew Graham, Dan Freedman, and Mark Gatiss, and he’s beaten them off. The BBC have finally caved in, and hell, it seems, is about to freeze over. There’s just one problem – Doctor Who’s already back. Sort of.
Because in the absence of anything on the box, Muirinn Lane Kelly has produced an animated story: Scream of the Shalka, starring Richard E Grant as a rather grizzly Ninth Doctor, facing off against a bunch of noisy insects in a Lancashire village. Told in six parts, it’s only been on the internet until now – so how will it fit into the BBC’s plans to resurrect the show?

shalka
Richard E Grant and Derek Jacobi in a rarely-glimpsed deleted scene from Scream of the Shalka (2005).

Davies describes it as ‘one of those crossroads moments’. “I had to make the hardest of decisions,” he says. “Because part of me – a big part – wanted to tear down everything that had the BBC had spent years protecting – religiously, almost – and start again. It was going to be my Batman: Year One. I’d have had homages to the past, of course, and recurring monsters, but I thought a rebranded, more accessible Doctor would have worked better with people who were seeing it for the first time.”
Rebranded? “It’s not as extreme as it sounds,” Davies insists. “There was plenty of scope for a show that was Doctor Who, but not as you know it. But then…”
There’s no need to finish his sentence, which as everyone knows (or really ought to, seeing as it’s a convention staple) concludes with the words ‘I saw Shalka’. The moment he did, Davies knew what he wanted. And thus, Paul Cornell’s TV adaptation of Scream of the Shalka was born.
“They’d put so much effort into it – the quality of the animation, the writing, the characterisation of the Doctor – that I really felt that to trample over all that would be criminally unfair. And they’d got Withnail as the Doctor. Withnail!”
russell-t-davies
Withnail, indeed, would go on to play the Doctor for three more years after his initial outing – which, of course, wasn’t his first time in the TARDIS. Years before, Grant had briefly portrayed the character in a Comic Relief sketch written by future showrunner Steven Moffat.
“Richard and I sat down at an early stage and talked about his turn on Curse of Fatal Death,” says Davies. “It’s a thirty-second appearance but he was wondering exactly how much it should inform the Doctor he was playing now. When I sketched out where we wanted to take him I told him that the Fatal Death Doctor was the one he should get out when he wanted to be charming, but that the wine-loving cynic from Shalka was basically going to be the default. I’d had an inner concern that he wouldn’t be on board with this, but as it turned out he loved the idea of a darker, slightly ambiguous Doctor – and so we went with that.”
When it came to adapting Shalka for the screen, Cornell found it rather less straightforward than he thought it would be. “I had to condense 70-odd minutes of narrative into just under 50,” he says. “That’s not so bad if you cut out the cliffhangers, which were no longer needed – but we did lose some of the characterisation in the process. Certain bits – exchanges between Alison and Joe, for example – I was able to slot into some of the later episodes as flashbacks, but the end result was slightly less even than I’d have liked. But that’s the price you pay when you switch mediums – you have to compromise.”
cursefatal
Richard E Grant’s original outfit. As also worn by Rowan Atkinson, Jim Broadbent, Hugh Grant, and Joanna Lumley.

Compromise, indeed, was the name of the game, particularly when it came to casting. “I really, really wish we’d been able to use Sophie Okonedo for Ali,” says Davies, “because she did such a smashing job on the web series. But she was just a little bit older than how I’d imagined the character being. Judy Garland just about got away with it in The Wizard of Oz, but audiences have grown a little less forgiving since then.”
We could nitpick whether or not he’s onto something about this. But in the event, the role of Ali – poor, tragic Ali – went to Naomie Harris, who would play the character over two series before her tear-jerking farewell at the end of Heaven’s Light. (So traumatic was her departure from the show that fans took to bulk-buying plush toy rabbits streaked with fake blood, in homage to that final scene.) It wasn’t the end of Okonedo’s association with Doctor Who – she managed to snag a recurring role as Ali’s half-sister Claire, even getting a brief trip in the TARDIS in the critically acclaimed Rise of the Myrka.
“Ali was great,” Cornell reminisces. “She was empowered, feisty and independent – curious and sometimes headstrong, but also grounded, very taken with the Doctor but also very frustrated with him. She takes most of her cues from Ace, who in many ways was the prototype for all the female companions we’ve had since.”
In fact, it was this sense of looking back that informed much of the direction that the creative team chose to adopt. Creations like the Borad and Sil made repeat appearances. And unanswered questions that had surfaced during Sylvester McCoy’s time on the show – what became known as ‘the Cartmel Masterplan’ – were finally resolved. The net result was a series that, while not the earth-shattering ratings winner that Davies had hoped for, did sufficiently well for the BBC to grant a second. The rest, as they say, is history.
ali
A tearful, unblinking Ali confronts the Weeping Angels in the closing scenes of Circuit Failure.

“I think we may not have been quite as accessible for newer viewers as we’d thought,” Davies admits. “But it turned out that there were plenty of older ones left, and they became the core audience. And the younger, less familiar share of the audience grew organically, and very steadily. It became like hearsay – there were people asking each other ‘What’s this great show everyone’s watching?’. But it took a while.”
There are so many wonderful stories in that first series – Scott & Wright’s Feast of the Stone, Shearman’s The Dalek Conundrum, and the Moffat-penned Things That Go Bump all spring to mind – but one of the highlights was Blood of the Robots, from veteran Who writer Simon Clark. “I had a lot of fun with that,” Clark says. “Some of the ideas for the robots had to be scaled down due to budget constraints, but it was incredibly rewarding seeing your work up on that screen. Plus kids loved it, even though half the cute robots wind up as scrap!”
And what of the Master – the Doctor’s nemesis, now shoehorned into the TARDIS as a (largely) benevolent android? When asked about him, Davies gives a rueful smile. “I think that’s the part of the show that didn’t really work to the extent that it should have,” he admits. “It’s no reflection on Derek Jacobi, who did a phenomenal job. But the problem is that once you put the Master into that sort of situation, there really isn’t much you can do with him. To all intents and purposes, he was Kamelion Mark II – a narrative dead end.”
kamelion
Jacobi’s Master was famously written out at the end of Grant’s first series, in the fiery inferno that was Liquid Gold, and it would be a few years before he returned – looking rather different.
“I’ve never had so much hate mail as I got the week Jane Horrocks first turned up,” Davies says. “Twitter practically imploded. There were calls for the writer’s head on a platter, which is dreadful for poor Mark, who turned in such a cracking script.”
There were three people on Davies’ casting shortlist for the new Master, but Horrocks was top of the bill. “She fired off so wonderfully against Anna [Maxwell Martin],” former producer Julie Gardner remembers. “I was there at that first read-through and the chemistry between them was absolutely electric.”
“It’s standard practice now, but you wouldn’t believe the controversy it caused at the time!” Davies remembers. “The Mail ran a headline that read ‘DOCTOR WHO IS DEAD’, or similar. Thing is, we’d already regenerated the Doctor into a woman – but this had the people upstairs wriggling in their seats. They were telling us we were going to kill the show.”
Not that certain executives would have seen this as a bad thing. “It’s no secret that the Series 3 ratings were pretty dismal,” Gardner acquiesces. “There was a sense that the show might not last much longer. It was 1986 all over again. They agreed to give Russell one more season as long as he changed Doctor. Which just meant that we felt bad for Richard, who’d been so great.”
blood
Daryl Joyce’s concept art for Feast of the Stone. (Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/vampires/gallery/joyce/feastofstone.shtml)

Davies concurs. “I think, in the end, that people just got tired of a bitter, cynical Doctor with a drinking problem,” he says. “There was a certain novelty value to it at first – it brought back some of the mystery to him that Bill Hartnell pioneered and Sylvester continued. I think people gave us a bit more slack than perhaps we deserved during those first two series, purely because it was Doctor Who and it was back – but by the end of Richard’s run they were switching off in droves, which is no reflection on him, more on the direction we’d taken with the scripts. The annoying thing, of course, is that Paramount went down the same route with Iron Man some years later – and everyone loved them for it!”
But in the end, Martin’s casting – though controversial with purists – was to be the salvation of the show, earning her a BAFTA in 2009. Audiences loved her, and so did the critics. “Anna Maxwell Martin practically sizzles with other worldly wonder,” Dan Martin wrote in The Guardian. “You instinctively want to take her hand and follow her into the flames of death, on any planet. It’s hard to imagine anyone else as Doctor Who.”
And what of Martin herself, and her reputation as ‘the second Tom Baker’?
“She did have a reputation for being difficult on set,” Russell Tovey – who played the Tenth Doctor’s first companion, Pete Winstead – admits. “But most of it was press sensationalism. She believed very strongly in the character and what it stood for, and sometimes that passion became a little inflamed when we were up against a deadline. But I never saw her act unprofessionally through all the time we spent together. It was probably the happiest year of my working life.”
horrocks_martin
Anna Maxwell Martin, Jane Horrocks, and Russell Tovey in a publicity shoot the three actors did for Black Nativity (2008).

It’s impossible to think that the revived Doctor Who – now in its 53rd year and showing no signs of slowing down – could have been produced any other way. Looking back, does the creative team have any regrets?
“I do wish we’d cracked the U.S.,” Gardner says. “I sometimes wonder how things might have been different if we’d gone for a slightly fresher approach that didn’t rely so much on existing continuity. But then that’s Doctor Who – it’s built on continuity.”
Davies agrees, at least up to a point. “I don’t think it’s as simple as saying that Doctor Who hasn’t worked in America because it’s still relying too much on its past,” he argues. “I think they’ve just got enough TV to be going along with. I’ve toyed with spin-offs, in case one of them piques an American network’s interest. At one point we were thinking about going back to Sarah Jane, but I wanted to road test her in Who first, and we never got our calendars in sync – although I do sometimes wonder if she wasn’t sure about the direction we’d taken. And then, of course, it was too late.”
However much we speculate on what could have been, there’s no doubt that despite the current furore over Mackenzie Crook’s contract, the revived Who has been a golden age, with the show enjoying a popularity in the UK that it hasn’t managed since the Hinchcliffe years. In amidst the highs and lows (“I think we can all agree,” says Davies, “that Triumph of the Daleks was a mistake”) it’s still rip-roaring entertainment, as well as providing a showcase for a wealth of talented actors. People like David Tennant, who made his on-screen Who debut in Shalka playing a caretaker, and who – at five appearances as we go to press – is one of the most prolific recurring guest performers.
martin-tennant
A steely-eyed Jensen watches the Doctor leave in the closing scenes of See How They Play (2010).

“David’s great,” Russell says. “He’ll do whatever you ask him and he always inhabits the characters completely. He wears them like a skin. When we cast him as Abshento in Siege of the Ice Warriors, he was outstanding. Look at that scene where he interrogates Richard and Richard turns the conversation on its head. That’s some of the best acting from the pair of them that I’ve ever seen, and that’s due in no small part to David.”
Is there any danger that viewers will become confused at the same actor in multiple roles? Davies scoffs at the notion. “I’m so tired of certain parties expecting the BBC to dumb down,” he says. “It didn’t bother people in the ’80s and it shouldn’t bother them now. Viewers are smart enough to know the difference. No one ever complained about Michael Sheard.”
And what about the possibility of David one day inheriting the mantle from Mackenzie, just as Colin Baker did from Peter Davison? On this front Davies is apparently hedging his bets. “He’d love to, I’m sure,” he says. “He’s been a fan for decades. But he’s one of the busiest actors in the business. After the third series of Blackpool, things just took off for him, particularly in theatre. His Benedick [opposite Miranda Hart, playing Beatrice in Much Ado About Nothing, summer 2011] was so well-received, I think that’s where his heart lies, at least for the time being.”
He offers another grin. “Still, you never know, right?”

]]>
https://thedoctorwhocompanion.com/2016/11/12/an-entirely-fictitious-account-of-the-richard-e-grant-years/feed/ 2 6538